Question: What If Lily Chose Snape?

Why did Snape not marry Lily?

Originally Answered: In the Harry Potter series, why didn’t Lily marry Snape.

The simple answer: She didn’t love him.

The more complicated answer: He proved again and again that he wasn’t willing to listen to Lily, respect her or her views, or love her in a healthy way..

How did Hermione die?

Beside this, does Hermione die in Harry Potter? On April 16, Hermione is attacked by a mountain troll in Hogwarts. Harry and Fred and George Weasley come help her. They fight and kill the troll but Hermione dies of her injuries.

Is Hermione Voldemort’s daughter?

Description: Hermione — the daughter of Tom Riddle, later — Voldemort`s. The father taught his daughter to hate and taught to her evil magic, so he thinks that Hermione certainly will gets in Slytherin. … Hermione, under the Imperio, went to school on the Hogwarts-Express.

Does Harry ever see Dudley again?

According to Pottermore, the last time Vernon and Petunia ever saw Harry was the day they left Privet Dr. in Deathly Hallows (See “15 times Harry Ruined the Dursleys’ Day #15). … in Deathly Hallows (See “15 times Harry Ruined the Dursleys’ Day #15). However, Harry did see Dudley again.

Does Snape love Harry?

Now, as firmly established, Snape was not the greatest fan of Harry, but that didn’t mean that he ever stopped loving Lily. Dumbledore was surprised that Snape seemed to care for the boy. With a swish of his wand, Snape conjured up a Patronus) – Lily’s Patronus, a doe. ‘Always,’ he said.

What would have happened if Lily married Snape?

For Lily and Snape to have gotten married she would have had to remain blind to his flaws. And a woman like Lily isn’t going to stay blind to your flaws forever. Worse case scenario they would have had a child together and that would have been the wake up call she needed.

Who loved Lily more Snape or James?

If we take this quote as foreshadowing what we would learn about Snape in book 7, it’s clear he was both obsessed with and in love with Lily. He loved her initially, probably more than James ever did, but he wasn’t able to let her go, therefore his love became a terrible obsession.

Who is the richest person in Harry Potter?

Nicholas Flammelit is Nicholas Flammel. He had more time than others to accumulate a massive amount of wealth as he lived for more almost 500 years. He was also in possession of the Philospher’s Stone which had the capacity to turn any object into gold. So this definitely makes Flammel the wealthiest character in Harry Potter world.

Is Snape the most important character?

Snape plays a crucial role but is not at the level in terms of book mentions and absolute importance to the overall plot as the trio and Dumbledore. I’d put Snape in the same group with Voldemort and Dumbledore.

Did Snape see Lily die?

Of course not. If Snape were there, he would not be skulking in the background waiting for all the damage to happen, and then go hug Lily’s dead body after it’s done. He would duel Lord Voldemort to the death. Snape probably knew, (being assured by Dumbledore) that the Potters are safe, and hidden.

Did Lily ever forgive Snape?

Many Hp fans are saying that Lily did not forgive Snape, but if we look into all the interviews with Rowling, we can see that she did forgive him. … Snape didn’t reply, so Lily knew immediately that he still wants to join the Death Eaters. So right there, she ended her friendship with Snape.

Why did Snape say Expecto Patronum?

“For him?” shouted Snape. “Expecto Patronum!” … By casting the patronus, Snape indirectly answered the headmaster that he still loved Lily. That all he did was for Lily’s sake and her death shocked him so much that his patronus took the form of Lilys’, whom he loved dearly.

Did Snape love Lily or obsessed?

Snape was not obsessed with Lily. He accepted her choice to end the friendship and apparently never even tried to contact her again. Severus still mourns her death a decade later but this is quite normal if you consider the fact that Lily was his best friend for years. Sirius still thinks a lot about James as an adult.

Is Snape more powerful than Voldemort?

12 More Powerful: Severus Snape Severus Snape might have pretended to serve Voldemort (while in fact, as we all know, working as a double agent for Dumbledore), but there’s almost no question he was more powerful than the Dark Lord.

Why does Voldemort kill Lily and James?

James and Lily were killed because they were standing in the way of the real goal, Harry’s death. … He repeated what he remembered, and so Voldemort sought to kill Harry as an infant in hopes to avoid being vanquished. However, Voldemort did not realise that by attempting to kill Harry, he was marking him as his equal.

Did Snape love Lily Potter?

The oddest thing about all of this? Professor Severus Snape. He was in the same year as Lily Evans and James Potter at Hogwarts – and he was deeply in love with Lily ever since he met her as a child. Snape was the same age as Lily and James – in fact, Rowling has confirmed that he was born in January 1960.

How were Lily and James so rich?

Harry’s money came from inheritance from his father, James. James was independently wealthy (from family money) when he left Hogwarts, sufficiently such that he was able to support himself, Sirius, and Lily as full-time (unpaid) fighters for the Order of the Phoenix.

Why did Lily chose James over Snape?

Why did Lily Evans choose James Potter over Severus Snape? Lily chose James because James proved so unyielding in his loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him. Snape could never do that while she lived. Only after her death did he finally learn how.

Did Lily like Snape?

Her refusal to do so even though she had a choice is what created the magic that protected Harry. The deep, unrequited love Snape held for Lily for almost all of his life also influenced his Patronus, which took the form of a silver doe – the same as hers, caused him to spy on Voldemort for Albus Dumbledore.

Was Lily pregnant when Voldemort killed her?

J.K. Rowling has revealed that Lily was pregnant with her second child, when Voldemort killed her. Even worse, she had finally talked James into making peace with Snape, and even wanted to make him the child’s godfather.

Is Snape evil or good?

Snape is evil: He’s a Death Eater, he has a longstanding grudge against Harry’s father, he’s been nothing but nasty to the boy since his arrival, and he’s generally an unpleasant fellow to be around. Oh, and by the way, he killed Dumbledore!

Why did James Potter hate Snape?

He was not lying when he said one of the reasons James hated Snape was because Snape was into Dark Arts. Snape was into Dark Arts by the scene in Snape’s Worst Memory. Snape had already invented or at least used Sectumsempra by then (which he used on James).

How did Lily feel about Snape?

No, Lily never loved Snape, and he only has himself to blame for losing her friendship. Yes Lily potter had a small crush on Snape when she was younger. James potter was Lily’s friend and he liked her. But when the James and Snape started fighting Lily took James side.

How did Lily fall in love with James?

Lily disliked James at first because their first interactions and his ego left her with a negative impression of him, even if she was attracted to him, so when he deflated his ego she was able to see his good qualities and they got together and fell in love.

Is Harry richer than Malfoy?

The Malfoy family are billionaires. … Draco’s FATHER was rich. Harry’s inheritance from his parents was all his, and then he also inherited a house and fortune from Sirius Black before he came of age. So, until Draco comes into his full inheritance, Harry is richer than Draco.

Why did Lily say always?

Harry asks, “Will you stay with me?” Lily says, “Always.” Is this a reference to Snape? No. It is a reference to a mothers love for her son. She will always be with Harry until he joins her in death.

Did Voldemort know Snape loved Lily?

Voldemort said that after Harry told him that Snape was on Dumbledore’s side because of Lily. … Voldemort didn’t know Snape loved Lily – he thought he just wanted her, the way you want a generous piece of pie or the very last cookie. He thought Snape wanted to possess her.

Why did Lily Potter die?

For our first post, I’ll be exploring Lily Potter’s death as Harry witnesses it in Voldemort’s memory in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. … Thus far, we know that Lily sacrificed herself to save her son in a calculated move to protect him from Voldemort.

Why do Snape and Lily both say always?

When Snape expressed his concern that Dumbledore was raising Harry like a pig for slaughter, Dumbledore asked if he has grown sensitive towards Harry. To this, Snape replies by producing a patronus, which is a doe. Lily’s patronus was a doe too. … Replying to this Snape said he always loved her, in short, “Always”.

What happened to Lily and James Potter?

James and Lily Potter were a married couple and the parents of the famous Harry Potter. They were both Gryffindor students at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry and members of the Order of the Phoenix. They were both murdered by Lord Voldemort on Hallowe’en in 1981, while trying to protect their infant son.